imposter syndrome
Planted Mar 2023 Tended 8 days ago
Contents
Mandy Brown turns imposter syndrome around in “Impostered”, asking what are the social and policy factors that cause people to feel like they don’t belong, and can we talk about those instead of blaming the individual.
In “Petered” Brown brings in Christian Gläßel and Adam Scharpf’s Making a Career in Dictatorship to consider what happens to actual imposters in an organization. Echoing Hannah Arendt’s notion of the banality of evil, Gläßel and Scharpf observe that ambitious individuals who rise beyond the level of their own competence and can no longer do better than their peers may be tempted to continue their ascent by doing worse: proving their utility and loyalty by taking on the organization’s “dirty work”:
The logic of career pressure also offers a compelling twist to the Peter Principle. The Principle posits that individuals in hierarchical organizations are promoted until they reach their level of incompetence, where they can no longer perform effectively and cease to advance. In contrast, our logic shows how these individuals may surpass this point and climb the hierarchy even further. Career-pressured individuals often take on high-risk, labor-intensive, or morally contentious tasks. By loyally executing the organization’s dirty work, they can reestablish their value, regain competitiveness, and even outpace peers who were previously ahead of them. (Christian Gläßel and Adam Scharpf, Making a Career in Dictatorship)
Brown brings it home:
What if the popularity of imposter syndrome is, in part, a means of obscuring the actual imposters in our midst? What are we missing when we look inward instead of around?